As a bi-coastal San Francisco expat, I occasionally feel choose I’m living a twin life. My West Coast friends check out me as a traitor for leaving the “Best Coast,” while my East Coast friends mock me for my Valley girl accent and sunny outlook — a stark comparison to the average no-nonsense, blunt New Yorker. 

Underlying these jibes, but, is a severe rivalry between the two cities, which feature wildly different ways of life. Having resided in both, here’s my attempt to judge the competition, damaged dvery own into 6 various categories. 

Transportation & Navigation — New York

For beginners, New York’s public transit mechanism is easier to pick up (I didn’t say “easy.” I said “easier”). All you must learn are the — albeit convoluted — submethod routes (and also bus lines, if applicable). Newcomers to San Francisco (SF) will struggle with the many kind of different transit systems: Bay Area Rapid Transit (additionally recognized as “BART,” an inter-city submethod that has some stops in SF), cable cars, the San Francisco Municipal Railway (Muni) and also Muni Metro. BART fares are also calculated based upon distance, while one swipe of a MetroCard will take you all over you want to go within the MTA system. If anything, the MTA is even more frustrating than challenging to understand also, as it’s infamous for regular delays and disruptive service changes.

You are watching: New york versus san francisco


Additionally, many type of Manhattan and Queens roadways are structured on a grid device, so finding out wbelow you are is a lot simpler. While San Francisco does have landnote roads (such as Market, Powell and Valencia) and its structure is somewhat gridchoose, it isn’t a true grid system. It’s even more favor a bunch of grids stitched together, and also its hilly building plus the myriad of public transit devices make it not exceptionally walkable and hard to navigate.

New York additionally gets bonus points for not having actually needles or humale feces by subway gates. 

Food — San Francisco

Culinary transformations don’t start in New York — they start in San Francisco. For circumstances, did you understand that tright here are three various types of burritos? The Mission-style burrito — the kind that a lot of civilization know as a burrito this day — has its roots in San Francisco, as does the “sushirrito,” which made headlines upon its creation in 2011. We additionally have a bustling Asian community and an official Japantown, which is somepoint that New York lacks.

New York does seem to have actually a greater thickness of European restaurants, and pizza joints (duh). San Francisco may not have actually pizza galore, however it outshines New York in its diversity and quality of food options: if you’re craving terrific Mexihave the right to or Chinese food, look nowright here else. Immigrant-established restaurants market authentic seasonings and also reasonable prices. If you’re willing to splurge a tiny, there’s certain to be a high-finish restaurant a couple of minutes away.

Sports — San Francisco

Let’s face it: the Yankees are overrated. San Franciscans love bonding over their sporting activities teams: the Giants, the Warriors and also, though not as a lot, the Niners. While the Giants and Warriors “dynasties” did lug in some fairweather fans in the last decade, our area stays together. 

We bonded together to stand also behind Mike Krukow, fifty percent of our beloved broadspreading duo Kruk & Kuip, when he revealed he was experiencing from a degenerative muscle illness. We started the #LetTimmySmoke project when Tim Lincecum was cited for marijuana possession — as many execute in SF, he was just “blazing it.” We cried as soon as the Warriors shed to the Cavs in 2016, and also we rejoiced when they won in ’15, ’17 and ‘18.

New York doesn’t seem to treatment around a team other than the Yankees. The Nets and Knicks? Fuhgeddahboudit. Tbelow are New York Giants fans out tright here, however some of them even bleed into — gasp — New Jersey. (I learned extremely quickly upon coming right here that you shouldn’t also cite the Mets.) Additionally, the Yankees have evolved previous a local sports area and also become even more of a cultural symbol: it’s hard to recognize if the perboy throughout from you wearing a Yankees hat is an actual fan or simply a tourist that thinks they must look prefer an authentic New Yorker.

SF Giants fans don’t have time to resolve hating on both the Mets and the Red Sox. We simply devote all our time to hating on the Dodgers.

Diversity — Tie

Statistically, New York is more ethnically and also linguistically varied than San Francisco, and also I’ve watched this play out anecdotally. I’ve never met even more Dominican, Puerto Rican and Jamaican human being than when I relocated to New York. There are likewise some really cool West Afrihave the right to restaurants that I’ve yet to attempt.

However before, LGBTQ civilization will certainly discover more of a house in San Francisco, wright here rainbow flags are ubiquitous and also Pride feels like component of the prevailing society. Both cities have actually Pride parades, but San Francisco parties harder. And choose I pointed out earlier, we have better Asian food. Good luck finding a Burmese restaurant in NYC — I might just discover one in NYC, which remained in Bensonhurst, a 60-minute trek from wbelow I live. 

People — San Francisco

New Yorkers are recognized for their perspective and rushed nature: both stereoforms are true. At the same time, you have to feel welconcerned chat up a San Franciscan while in line or say hello while biking past them in Golden Gate Park — friendliness is the norm in The golden state. Arguably, our accents are more pleasant, too. We probably attempt to compensate for the omnipresent fog via our cheery perspectives.

Also, if you ask someone for directions in New York, possibilities are they’ll tell you, however you’ll have to pay the price of a dirty look.

Arts, Culture & Innovation — New York

Which city is the residence of Broadmethod, the Metropolitan Museum of Art (Met) and also the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)? NYC, of course. The Met, frequently called the ideal museum in the human being, deserves that praise — it’s vast, boasts a broad range of art from different geographical areas and also time durations, and also can take days to really unpack. San Francisco has its own MoMA, yet it withers in comparikid to NYC’s many kind of MoMA branches. Art enthusiasts and liberal arts lovers will have a lot more fun in NYC’s many type of museums, comedy clubs and theatres.

See more: Is There Going To Be A Season 5 Of Alexa And Katie ? Will There Be A Season 5 Of Alexa And Katie

San Franciscans are as well focused on their startups or STEM ventures to pay any type of attention to the arts. For eincredibly museum or indie art gallery, it seems favor five startup service providers are born. It’s becoming a place where coding languages could rearea actual langueras in the list of many typically spoken ones in the close to future.


Which city wins out? Eventually, it depends on who you are. As a humanities significant and aesthete, I feel at residence in NYC. On the other hand, STEM majors will certainly discover even more project prospects in San Francisco, where there is more demand for young talent. In the finish, I’m happy being in the concrete jungle wbelow desires (and student debt) are made of … but as soon as my hankerings for Burmese food hit, my mind drifts ago to the foggy skies and smelly roadways I organize dear.